girlontheleft ([info]girlontheleft) wrote,
@ 2007-05-13 08:52:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend  Next Entry
Some people just have issues, others have a hold box.
Holy crap, I just got linked on When Fangirls Attack for my comments on the Superhero Bratz Babyz. And just when I was trying to think of something to write up about that phenomenally awful Mary Jane statuette that everyone is up in arms about. Well, hey, it's not quite a doll per se, but close enough.

My take: I really don't mind the original concept art so much, because MJ looks cute and human and a bit goofy, and I can imagine she's just teasing an unclad Spidey who's just out of frame. But the "comiquette" (bleah) looks remarkably unlike its supposed inspiration. Someone at Sideshow — possibly several people — must really honestly have thought she'd be way hotter if she looked more gaunt and haggard, like an aging heroin addict. And greasier. And more evil. Seriously, check out that facial expression. You'd think she's a fembot with a spring-loaded Spidey-killer death cannon hidden somewhere in her buttocks and she's taking aim at him. Or something.

As for the WFA link, I'm kind of flattered because (as a bit of an aspiring comics artist myself) I read that blog all the time... but I'm a little worried that I could get some nasty anti-Bratz comments and have to clean up the ensuing mess. I've noticed that even very self-aware, analytical feminists can end up mindlessly falling into the same old "OMG BRATZ R WHOREZ (cuz of whut they wear LOL) LETS CALL HER NAMEZ" slut-shaming routine, or go into the "I didn't play with silly, frivolous girls' toys as a child, I played with superior masculine boys' toys, aren't I a unique little snowflake?" nonsense, without even realizing how they're endorsing misogyny. For the record: I'm a feminist, and I read comics and collect Bratz dolls, and I don't think that's a contradiction.

Oh, and on a happier note: Scott McCloud is coming to town! Yay!



(5 comments) - (Post a new comment)


[info]pikapika217
2007-05-13 05:13 pm UTC (link)
anti-bratz people bother me so much because they take everything at face value, and if they really though it out, they'd realize that Babs is actually a worse roll model for girls

Ok, so yeah, sure, they dress in little clothing, but they also command respect. for instance in the song 'Nobody's girl':

-sample lyrics-

I'm nobody's girl
no one's gonna tell me what to do
I'm nobody's girl
Don't treat me like I belong to you
I'm nobody's girl
Oh baby, If I'm with you it's cause I choose to be
Nobody owns me


And they praise and acknowledge inner beauty in songs like Diamondz:

-sample lyrics-

Diamondz is a girl that glows
from her head to her toes
Inside counts, really, really, really, really
and that's what makes a girl pretty, pretty, pretty, pretty



I mean, Isn't feminism about things like that? Barbie has never stood on her own in the way they do. They don't need men. A real woman can command and demand respect in anything and everything they where. And dolls can't be whores, no equipment. Also, If you hate them so much, why buy them for your children in the first place. I know I there are things I wanted as a kid that my mom said no too, and I didn't have them, period.

Stop blaming everything but your lack of good parenting for the outcome of your children! There are other dolls, you know.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


(Anonymous)
2007-05-14 09:10 am UTC (link)
To be fair to Barbie...she does hold down about five jobs, doctor, vet, aeroplane pilot, teacher...etc.
And she seems to be the sole carer for her 2 or 3 little sisters. And she still has time to be an ice dancer, fairy and princess! (I wouldsay she still manages to make time for Ken too, but she dumped him, didn't she?)

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]snarky_imp
2007-05-13 05:56 pm UTC (link)
The artwork is cute, but oi, something was seriously lost in translation. As a result, I think I have to go spork my eyes out. Now.

(Reply to this)


[info]ltms
2007-05-14 07:24 am UTC (link)
Sorry. Bratz is reprehensible.

(Reply to this)


[info]furikku
2007-05-14 03:06 pm UTC (link)
In from WFA (you showed up AGAIN! Woo!)

I don't like Bratz mainly because I don't like their style, and I haven't seen anything like "Undercover Narc Bratz" or "Barbarian Bratz" to make up for it. OTOH, Barbie didn't do quite as much as that, either.

I was a She-Ra gal, myself. Pretty princesses with swords!

(Reply to this)


(5 comments) - (Post a new comment)

Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…